Here is something that troubles me. (It should trouble you too.)
Political parties campaign by showcasing their candidates. They introduce them to communities, promote their achievements, credibility and leadership qualities, and encourage people to vote for them.
When voters choose a party because of the people it presents
Ellen Pakkies and Mohamed Ikbal Salwary are well-known community figures whose reputations may have influenced voters to support the National Coloured Congress – NCC.
Now imagine voting for a political party partly because you believe those individuals will represent you in council, only to discover that they may not be taking up those positions.
Yes, the law allows political parties to amend their PR lists through prescribed IEC procedures.
But is everything that is legally permissible necessarily fair to the voter?
In our proportional representation system, voters cast their ballots for political parties, not individual PR candidates. However, parties know very well that the people they showcase influence voting decisions. If candidates who helped attract public support are subsequently replaced, surely voters deserve to know why?
AND THIS IS EXACTLY THE POINT!
Voters need explanations when a party changes its PR List post elections
We do not know the circumstances surrounding these apparent changes. We do not know whether there were resignations, personal decisions, internal agreements or other legitimate reasons.
And precisely because we do not know, we are owed an explanation!
We are not accusing anyone of wrongdoing. We are asking for transparency.
When you use people’s credibility to win public confidence, you have a responsibility to explain significant changes in representation.
Political parties may legally control their candidate lists, but they should never take voter trust for granted.
How disappointing it would be if voters supported a party because of certain individuals, only to discover afterwards that those individuals would not represent them.
Transparency is not a favour to voters. It is a responsibility owed to them, and ordinary citizens should never be criticised for demanding it.
Sidelining can never be the answer!
NCC PR List Reshuffle not illegal but where is the transparency?
Nobody is suggesting that changes to a certified candidate list are automatically unlawful.
Candidates may resign, decline positions, become ineligible or be replaced through lawful procedures.
But what happened in this particular case?
The published NCC PR candidate list places Ellen Pakkies at number 1 and Mohamed Ikbal Salwary at number 2, yet neither appears among the five individuals now being presented as elected councillors.
Why were they bypassed? Did they resign? Was the list amended? Were the correct procedures followed? Who authorised the changes, and when?
These are reasonable questions that deserve factual answers.
Voters Deserve Transparency
Instead, the absence of an official explanation has created unnecessary speculation, confusion and questions about the fairness of the process. The NCC can put an end to this by publishing the relevant documentation and explaining exactly how the five councillors were determined.
This is not about questioning the suitability of those selected. It is about transparency, fairness and accountability.
If everything was done correctly, surely there should be no difficulty explaining the process?
Read More About Elections 2026
A certified candidate list should mean something. Otherwise, what is the purpose of publishing it?
Transparency is not an attack on a political party. It is a basic expectation of democratic accountability.
The public deserves clarity, not speculation!

